News & Media

Why India Lost So Many Lives In Kargil

प्रवक्ता · 19 July 2018 · 2 min read

The truth is that on the orders of the White House, Vajpayee had tied the IAF hand and foot and forbidden them from overflying Pakistani Air Space. The then PAF Chief is on record as saying that as the IAF did not enter Pakistani territory, what was going on was not a Pakistani concern.

Kargil was a fiasco that shows cased the vacuum in integrity and competence in both India’s military and civilian “leadership” The Air Force and artillery should have pounded the Pak positions BEFORE the infantry were ordered to retake the fortified heights. NOT after they were already within 50 yards (OR less as per eye witness accounts) from the enemy bunkers.

Kargil is a cover-up of India's inadequacies. India lost thousands of soldiers (covered up and made out to be less than five hundred) to recover land that was India's own to begin with. It was a failure in intelligence, in logistics (the ammunition for the artillery arrived after the soldiers had been sacrificed to recover the heights from Pakistan's entrenched and fortified "Northern Light Infantry".

There were no Anti-SAM decoys leading to the downing of a MiG, a chopper and the withdrawal of the Air Force), in command and control (the infantry battalions was ordered to retake the heights without air or artillery cover while even a Platoon commander knows to lay a mortar barrage and smoke screen before ordering bayonets to be fixed), and the pusillanimity of the leadership (Vajpayee, in a Nehru redux, squealed to the US and took their advise to ground the IAF and proscribe their flight over Pakistan).

At the end of the day, the poor infantry, who are "paid to die"according to India's Neta-Babu-Millard-Cop-Crony Kleptocrats had to take the brunt.

Colonel Lalit Rai, Rtd.  (VrC) with the author

My junior from the NCC came out with just four survivors and a basket full of gallantry awards from his Battalion, 1/XI GR (approx 1000 soldiers) after retaking just one of the promontories.

– S.Suchindranath Aiyer

Also read,

Five Things You Should Know About Indo-Russia S-400 Deal

Did Nirmala Sitharaman really accept the beheading of Pak soldiers

Indian Army Will Soon Have Force Multiplier 155mm 52 Cal Mounted Gun system

Indian Companies and Russian OEMs Sign 7 MoUs for Defence Hardware during Defexpo 2018

When Raksha Mantri and Three Services Chiefs Appeared in a TV Series

Cite this article

प्रवक्ता. “Why India Lost So Many Lives In Kargil”. YugSamvad, 19 July 2018. https://yugsamvad.com/articles/why-india-lost-so-many-lives-in-kargil

ShareWhatsAppXFacebook

Related reading

Shri Guruji Golwalkar on the Post-Partition Muslim Crisis
Dharma & Culture

Shri Guruji Golwalkar on the Post-Partition Muslim Crisis

Shri Guruji’s explicit view regarding the inherent disposition of Muslims and the impending national crisis arising therefrom is found in his book *Vichar Navaneet* (*Bunch of Thoughts*); Shri Guruji says, “After Partition, there are many who say that the Muslim problem no longer exists at all. Pakistan

23 October 2026 · 4 min read

Dharma & Culture

The Meaning of Medha, Kautuhala, Jigyasa and Herd Mentality

*Medha* (intellect) and the Herd “He who protects *dharma* (righteousness/cosmic order), *dharma* protects him.” The meaning of *dharma* is Vedic *yajna* (sacrificial ritual), that is, the *karma-kanda* (ritual section) of the Vedas. There are ten characteristics of *dharma* — *dhriti* (fortitude), *kshama* (forgiveness), *dama* (self-control), *asteya* (non-stealing), *shaucha* (purity), *indriya-nigraha* (sensory control), *dhi* (intellect), *vidya* (knowledge), *satya* (truth), and *akrodha* (absence of anger). But these are merely characteristics on the basis of which we can recognize that a particular...

18 October 2026 · 8 min read

Politics & History

What is Theatre Command, why India needs it

On January 1st 2020 when India got its first CDS General Bipin Rawat, Mandate from the government was very clear. He has to bring jointness and Synergy among Army, Navy, and Air Force. Essentially theatre commands are Geographic units where all assets in that particular geographi

5 March 2021 · 3 min read