The Ancient Basis and Distinctiveness of the Jati System

Wherever we look in the world, nature-given diversity, specificity, distinction of eligibility and ineligibility (adhikara and anadhikara), and their innate harmony are effortlessly visible. Across all animals, birds, trees, stone, metal, and other insentient and sentient entities, a chain born of specific distinction is apparent. This distinction-laden diversity of nature and the unity arising from its gradation continually sustains the unfolding of this world. Among living beings, this specific distinction is termed breed or jati (birth-group or caste). Just as among dogs there are breeds like the Pomeranian, German Shepherd, and so forth. Even an insentient substance like coal exists in varieties such as anthracite, bituminous, peat, and others. The fundamental causes of this variation are their places or modes of origin. In the natural order, the qualities of an effect correspond strictly to the qualities of its cause, a principle acknowledged by modern science as well. According to their respective capacities, nature—without any partiality—ordains a hierarchy of higher and lower among all things. Failing to grasp the significance of this diversity and distinction, and denying it, would shatter the entire cosmic order of creation.

Therefore, the shastrakaras (scriptural authors), understanding this natural order, regulated the chaturvarna (the fourfold varna system) for the holistic and organic elevation of humanity. Free from attachment, aversion, and partiality, the system of chaturvarna is a God-ordained order in Sanatana Dharma. In the Vedic varna vyavastha (varna order), studying, teaching, and illuminating the wisdom of the Vedas and shastras is regarded as the innate attribute of Brahmins; valor, governance, and warfare as the attribute of Kshatriyas; agriculture and commerce as the attribute of Vaishyas; and diverse service projects, physical labor, and consummate mastery in arts and crafts as the natural attributes of Shudras. In the Purusha Sukta of the Rigveda, the limbs of the Virat Purusha (the Cosmic Being) are described. The seed of the Vedic varna order is the mantra of this very hymn. The limbs of the Virat Purusha from which the respective varnas are declared to have originated in the richa (Vedic verse) correspond completely to the natural qualities of those respective varnas. The mantra states,

ब्राह्मणोऽस्य मुखामासीद्वाहू राजन्यः कृतः। ऊरू तदस्य यद्वैश्यः पद्भ्यां शूद्रो अजायत॥ Rigveda 10.90, Yajurveda,  Chapter 31 “From the mouth of that Virat Purusha, the Supreme Soul, the Brahmins were born; from His arms, the Kshatriyas; from His abdomen, the Vaishyas; and from His feet, the Shudras were born.”

Western scholars such as Max Müller and Griffith, along with their Indian disciples, propagated a distorted interpretation of this, working to sow discontent and enmity in society. They disseminated malicious propaganda claiming that in Sanatana Dharma, Shudras were deliberately described as having originated from the feet in order to humiliate them. Their view is that feet are contemptible parts of the body, connection with which indicates indignity. In this manner, they sowed the seeds of hatred among the Shudras.

According to the shastras, this Virat Purusha is none other than Bhagavan Vishnu Himself. In the Shanti Parva of the Mahabharata, it is stated:

ततः कृष्णो महाभागः पुनरेव युधिष्ठिर। ब्राह्मणानां शतं श्रेष्ठं मुखादेवासृजत प्रभु:।। बाहुभ्यां क्षत्रियशतं वैश्यानामूरुतः शतम्। पद्भ्यां शूद्रशतश्चैव केशवो भरतर्षभ।। - Mahabharata, Shanti Parva, Chapter 206, Verse 35 “O Yudhishthira, then Lord Krishna created a hundred foremost Brahmins from His mouth, a hundred Kshatriyas from His arms, a hundred Vaishyas from His thighs, and a hundred Shudras from His feet, O bull among the Bharatas!”

Yet the reality is that the Shudras’ origin from the feet of the Virat Purusha Vishnu does not demean them; rather, it elevates their honor. The feet of Vishnu (Vishnupada) are also called mokshapada (the seat of liberation). In Sanatana Dharma, the feet of Shri Bhagavan hold supreme preeminence. Adherents of Sanatana Dharma do not seek refuge at the mouth of Virat Purusha Vishnu, nor do they seek the touch of His arms, nor the shelter of His abdomen; rather, they seek solely the shelter of His feet, whence the Shudra varna emerged. As it is said:

‘श्रीरामचन्द्रचरणौ मनसा स्मरामि। श्रीरामचन्द्रचरणौ वचसा गृणामि। श्रीरामचन्द्रचरणौ शिरसा नमामि। श्रीरामचन्द्रचरणौ शरणं प्रपद्ये॥’ ^- Shri Ramaraksha Stotram, Verse 29 (“With my mind I remember the feet of Shri Ramachandra; with my speech I praise the feet of Shri Ramachandra; with my head I bow to the feet of Shri Ramachandra; at the feet of Shri Ramachandra I take refuge.”)

In Vedic culture, the prescribed method of greeting a venerable person is charanasparsha (touching the feet). If the feet were inferior, why would touching the feet hold such reverence? For the other varnas, moksha (liberation) is attained through elaborate spiritual disciplines and the rigorous observance of Vedic duties, whereas Shudras, being declared as born directly from the lotus feet of Vishnu, are effortlessly granted moksha through the dharma of service. Therefore, the Shudra varna ought not to fall into the trap spun by Westerners.

Today, the senseless opposition mounted against the varna system and the jati system born from it has injected disorder, corruption, incompetence, inefficiency, and animosity into society. The arts have declined. Branches of traditional learning have disappeared. Avenues of livelihood have shrunk. Yet in India, the greatest number of livelihoods were hereditarily available to the Shudra jatis. One jati received the occupation of weaving cloth, another became tailors through sewing, another became carpenters through woodwork, another became blacksmiths through ironwork, others became barbers, potters, sculptors, tanners, weavers, washermen, acrobats, Doms, bards, engravers, and so forth. In this manner, distinct jatis received separate occupations, which continue traditionally to this day. These very jatis possess consummate mastery in their respective crafts, and this skill passes down through them hereditarily. The speed with which a blacksmith's son learns ironwork cannot be matched in speed or quality by someone from another jati. Because of this, full employment prevailed in society, and unemployment did not exist. All the needs of society were fulfilled collaboratively by all jatis.

The organic unity of society can be understood through the yajna (sacrificial rite). In a yajna, the participation of all jatis is indispensable. A description of this is found in the Ramayana.
“While arranging Dasharatha’s Putreshti yajna, Maharshi Vashishtha summoned elderly Brahmins adept in ritual acts and proficient in sacrificial crafts, servants assisting in the rites, artisans, carpenters, earth-diggers, astrologers, craftsmen, actors and dancers, scriptural scholars, and others, instructing them in the management of the yajna.” ^[1]
“Let such arrangements be made that people of all varnas are suitably honored and receive due respect.” ^[2]
Thereafter, Vashishtha called Sumantra and said, "Invite to this yajna all the righteous kings, Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas, and thousands of Shudras across this earth."^[3]

On the strength of the jati system, Indian society remained prosperous for centuries. All Indian crafts and products, including Indian muslin and spices, commanded dominance in world history. Alongside prosperity, the jati system also safeguarded Indian culture. It is solely due to the jati system that Indian society remained protected from alien Christian and Muslim cultures; otherwise, like Africa, it too would have become a permanent colony of Christianity. The jati system was the biggest thorn in the path of conversion before the missionaries. Alexander Duff, a prominent Christian missionary who arrived in India in the nineteenth century, wrote: "Idolatry and superstition (Hindu ritualism) are like the stones and bricks of a huge fabric (Hinduism), and caste is the cement which pervades and binds the whole. We will undermine this foundation, and both will tumble at once and form a common ruin."^[7]

From this admission, it is evident that, in the society of that time, destroying the jati system was deemed paramount for the destruction of Hinduism. And the assault upon and distortion of the jati system was carried out precisely with this objective. The jati system was the strength of Sanatana Dharma. A varna system based purely on karmana (action or occupation) is not tenable on scriptural, natural, or scientific grounds. Moreover, varna-sankara (intermixture of varnas) will lead society toward degradation. Therefore, the jati system, established by the shastras and sustained through an unbroken tradition within Sanatana Dharma, is thoroughly natural, scientific, and the path of innate human elevation; its preservation is imperative.

References :

1. Valmiki Ramayana, Balakanda, Sarga 13, Verses 6–8
2. Valmiki Ramayana, Balakanda, Sarga 13, Verse 14
3. Valmiki Ramayana, Balakanda, Sarga 13, Verse 20
4. “Idolatry and superstition are like the stones and bricks of a huge fabric, and caste is the cement which pervades and binds the whole. Let us undermine the foundation and both will tumble at once and form a common ruin.” – Alexander Duff, India and Indian Missions, Edinburgh, 1840, p. 616

Also Read 

Who Were the Shudras? What Did the Shudras Do?

Karapatra-ratna-samuccaya and Trad-ism

Sant Ravidas and Contemporary Society

The Interdependent Relationship Between Brahmins and Kshatriyas

Does the Purusha Sukta of the Rigveda Insult Shudras?

Who is Foremost Among the Four Varnas in Sanatana Dharma?

Shri Ram Eating the Tasted Ber Berries of Bheelni Shabari is Proven from Valmiki Ramayana